Wednesday, December 1, 2010

This is timely

The Russian Duma has passed a resolution that condemned Stalin and Soviet officials for the murder of Polish officers at Katyn and two other camps. About time, too. Needless to say, the Communist Party argued vehemently against the resolution but was outvoted. Of course, this is not a completely new move. The Russian government acknowledged the crime in 1992 but since then several newspapers close to successive governments revived the old story of the Germans being responsible.
Earlier this year a few key documents to do with Stalin's and Beria's guilt were published on the internet.
Nobody has ever been convicted over the massacre, with Russian prosecutors arguing that those responsible are now dead.

A Russian judicial investigation in 2005 only confirmed the execution of 1,803 victims, while the actual number of Polish prisoners killed at Katyn and other Soviet sites is generally held to be about 22,000, including about 8,000 military officers.

The Duma declaration called for the massacre to be investigated further in order to confirm the list of victims.

The Duma also argued that Katyn was a tragedy for Russia too as thousands of Soviet citizens were executed and buried in ditches there in the years 1936-38, the period of Soviet history known as the Terror.
Which is undoubtedly true. Indeed, it is part of the evidence that the Polish officers were executed in exactly the same way as their "predecessors" in the mass graves.

This will undoubtedly make President Medvedev's forthcoming visit to Poland a happier occasion.

The Wall Street Journal, in its article on the subject, adds an interesting and very moving tale.
Other than WikiLeaks, two notable events occurred over the weekend: Russia's parliament issued a resolution taking responsibility for Stalin's murder of 22,000 Polish officers in Katyn forest in 1940, and Dave Brubeck celebrated his 90th birthday in a set at the Blue Note jazz club in New York City. Permit us to connect the dots of history.

....

Toward the end of a long and very fine set Saturday evening at the Blue Note with his quartet, Mr. Brubeck, who turns 90 next week, took hold of the microphone aside his piano and began to talk about a remembrance of Poland. He said that President Eisenhower had sent the Dave Brubeck Quartet to Poland in 1958 to perform as representatives of the American people. Earlier in his career, Mr. Brubeck had represented the American people as a member of Patton's Third Army in Europe.

After a visit to Chopin's home and being surrounded by "all these pianos," Mr. Brubeck composed a Chopinesque jazz piece with the Polish name "Dziekuje." Mr. Brubeck asked if anyone in the Blue Note audience knew what "dzieuke" means. "It means 'thank you,'" a lady called out.

"That's right," said Mr. Brubeck. "It means thank you. And I want to play this piece as thanks to the people of Poland for resisting Soviet Communism."
One of the many things Hitler and Stalin had in common was their dislike for and distrust of jazz.

4 comments:

  1. If I remember rightly, left wing clerics in the Church of England (no doubt encouraged by the FCO) refused the Poles a site for a public memorial to Katyn in London on the grounds that it might upset relations with the Soviet Union. This was long after everyone knew that it was one atrocity which the Nazis did not commit. I hope that Hitler and Stalin were given front seats in their infernal abode and made to listen to the Brubeck piece - eternally.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like the idea of listening to the Brubeck piece eternally, though I wouldn't think that was punishment. I love Brubeck.

    The Katyn Memorial did eventually go up but there was a great deal of opposition and no official person was present at the unveiling. I really should add that now that the Duma has acknowledged Soviet guilt, the FCO might like to do the same. This does not show the FCO in a particularly good light: http://www.fco.gov.uk/en/about-us/who-we-are/our-history/historical-publications/research-projects/katyn/introduction/katyn-in-cold-war/

    ReplyDelete
  3. The tyrants messages were drummed to a pounding, primal and even charasmatic beat. The sub-rythmns of jazz were anathema to them as it de-focused the thoughts of the people onto a myriad of impulses.

    Correlation of the prominence of (particular streams of) music to the (human society's) discount rate, through the ages, would be a good research topic, to while-away the evenings ??

    ReplyDelete
  4. The tyrants messages were drummed to a pounding, primal and even charasmatic beat. The sub-rythmns of jazz were anathema to them as it de-focused the thoughts of the people onto a myriad of impulses.

    Correlation of the prominence of (particular streams of) music to the (human society's) discount rate, through the ages, would be a good research topic, to while-away the evenings ??

    ReplyDelete